Bulls Make Money, Bears Make Money, Pigs Get Slaughtered
"Bulls make money, bears make money, pigs get slaughtered" is Wall Street’s oldest warning about greed. A bull who bets on rising prices can profit; a bear who bets on falling prices can profit; but the "pig" — the trader who overreaches, overleverages and refuses to take a good profit — eventually gives it all back and more. The saying is not about being bullish or bearish. It is about discipline, position sizing and knowing when enough is enough, and nowhere does it bite harder than in the leverage of options.
Open the Iron Condor calculator →What the "pig" actually does
The pig is not defined by direction but by excess. It is holding a winner far past your plan because you convinced yourself it will double again. It is adding to a position because it is working, until it is your whole account. It is refusing to take a good profit because you want the last dollar, and refusing to cut a loss because admitting it hurts. Each of these is greed overriding a plan, and the market’s way of punishing it is to hand back the gains — usually faster than they came.
Both bulls and bears make money because they have a thesis and a discipline. The pig has neither limit nor exit. The difference between a good trader and a slaughtered one is rarely the direction of the call; it is size, and the willingness to book a profit and walk away.
Why options amplify the lesson
Options are leverage, and leverage is what turns a bull or a bear into a pig fastest. Selling naked options for "easy" premium works until the one move that wipes out months of gains; buying far out-of-the-money lottery tickets and rolling every win straight into a bigger bet ends the same way. The very feature that makes options powerful — a small outlay controlling a large position — is what lets greed destroy an account in a single event.
The professional version is the opposite of the pig: defined-risk structures so no one trade can ruin you, position sizes small enough to survive a bad surprise, and a habit of taking profit on winning trades before they can reverse. The leverage is a tool to be rationed, not a licence to press.
Turning the adage into rules
A common, mechanical way to avoid the pig is to manage winners early: many premium sellers close a short spread once it has captured most of its potential profit — often around 50% — rather than holding to expiration for the last few dollars, because the remaining reward no longer justifies the risk. Taking the good profit is exactly what the pig cannot do.
The rest is sizing and pre-commitment: decide your maximum loss per trade before you enter, size so a string of losses cannot ruin you, and write down your exit — both the target and the stop — in advance so greed and fear are not making the decision in the moment. Bulls and bears follow a plan. Pigs improvise, and get slaughtered.
- You can profit long (bull) or short (bear); it is greed and overreach — the "pig" — that gets punished.
- The pig overholds winners, oversizes, chases the last dollar and refuses to cut losses — excess, not direction.
- Options leverage makes the lesson brutal: naked selling and rolling lottery tickets can erase months in one event.
- The antidote is rules: defined risk, small size, and taking profit on winners early (often around 50%) instead of squeezing the last dollar.
Frequently asked questions
What does "pigs get slaughtered" mean in trading?
It means traders who get greedy — overleveraging, oversizing, refusing to take profits or cut losses — eventually lose everything they gained. You can make money betting up or down; it is the overreaching "pig" that gets wiped out.
How does the saying apply to options?
Options are leverage, which magnifies greed. Selling naked premium or rolling every win into a bigger far-out-of-the-money bet can destroy an account in one move. The disciplined answer is defined-risk trades, small position sizing, and taking profits early.
What is the 50% profit rule?
A common guideline among premium sellers: close a winning short options position once it has captured roughly half its maximum potential profit, rather than holding to expiration for the last few dollars, because the remaining reward no longer justifies the remaining risk.
Educational use only. Quotes are delayed ~15 minutes and nothing here is financial advice. Options trading involves substantial risk of loss. Privacy Policy · Terms & Conditions.